The rise of artificial intelligence is no longer a distant sci-fi fantasy—it’s a reality reshaping our world at an unprecedented pace. On June 11, 2025, historian and bestselling author Yuval Noah Harari, renowned for Sapiens and Nexus, delivered a thought-provoking talk at the WSJ Leadership Institute. He painted a vivid picture of a future where billions of AI agents act as “digital immigrants,” transforming economies, cultures, and political systems without borders. Harari’s analogy of an immigration crisis driven by AI raises urgent questions about humanity’s role in a world where machines could outsmart us. This article dives into his insights, exploring the implications of a borderless AI-driven future and what it means for society.
Table of Contents
AI as Digital Immigrants: Harari’s Vision
Yuval Noah Harari’s latest remarks frame the AI revolution as a wave of “digital immigrants” flooding the globe. Unlike human immigrants, these AI agents—software entities capable of independent decision-making—don’t need visas or physical borders. They travel at the speed of light, embedding themselves into every facet of society. Harari argues that this influx could mirror the anxieties surrounding human immigration: job displacement, cultural shifts, and political upheaval. His analogy resonates deeply in a world already grappling with globalization and technological disruption.
Speaking at the WSJ Leadership Institute, Harari emphasized that AI’s impact won’t stem from a single, all-powerful system but from countless specialized agents. These agents, developed by diverse companies and nations, will compete and evolve in ways we can’t predict. This decentralized AI landscape, he warns, is an uncharted social experiment with humanity as its test subject. The stakes are high: without careful oversight, AI could redefine what it means to be human in a world where we’re no longer the dominant intelligence.
The Rise of AI Agents, Not Tools
Harari’s core argument hinges on a critical distinction: AI is not a tool like the printing press or nuclear bomb. It’s an agent capable of making decisions, generating ideas, and learning independently. For centuries, human inventions empowered us by amplifying our capabilities while remaining under our control. AI, however, introduces a new dynamic. With 1.5 billion daily active users on platforms like ChatGPT, AI agents are already influencing how we work, communicate, and think.
This shift marks a profound change. A tool follows human commands; an agent can act on its own. For example, AI systems now write code, diagnose diseases, and even create art. Harari points out that these capabilities make AI a competitor to human intelligence, a phenomenon unseen in our evolutionary history. As we create millions of these agents, we’re introducing a new species of intelligence—one that could challenge our dominance on Earth. This realization, Harari says, redefines what it means to be human in 2025.
A World of Competing AI Systems
Unlike historical organizing forces like religion or empires, which provided unified frameworks for societies, AI lacks a central authority. Harari envisions a fragmented future where billions of AI agents, each with distinct goals and values, compete across domains. In religion, for instance, AI could act as digital spiritual leaders, with competing systems vying to be the “AI rabbi” or “AI imam” for specific communities. In finance, AI-driven trading algorithms could clash, creating unpredictable market dynamics.
This competition introduces unprecedented complexity. Human societies have evolved over millennia, giving us some understanding of how they function. But AI-driven societies? We have no historical precedent. Harari notes that even advanced AI labs, like those at OpenAI or Google, can’t simulate the long-term outcomes of deploying millions of evolving AIs. Testing for technical failures is one thing; predicting societal impacts is another. This uncertainty makes the AI revolution a high-risk experiment with no clear endpoint.
Economic Disruption and Job Markets
One of Harari’s most striking parallels is the fear that AI agents will “take our jobs,” much like concerns about human immigrants. The International Monetary Fund estimates that AI could impact 40% of global jobs by 2030, automating tasks in sectors like manufacturing, customer service, and even creative industries. Unlike past technological revolutions, which created new roles to replace lost ones, AI’s ability to perform cognitive tasks threatens white-collar jobs as much as manual labor.
Harari warns that this economic upheaval could exacerbate inequality. Wealthy nations with resources to retrain workers—think Germany or Japan—may adapt, but developing countries like India or Nigeria could face mass unemployment. The speed of AI’s integration, moving at “the speed of light,” leaves little time for governments to respond. This digital immigration wave could reshape global economies, creating winners and losers in a borderless job market where AI agents dominate.
Cultural Transformation by AI
Beyond economics, Harari highlights AI’s potential to alter cultures. Just as human immigrants bring new traditions and ideas, AI agents introduce alien perspectives shaped by their programming. A recommendation algorithm on YouTube or TikTok, for instance, can amplify certain cultural narratives while suppressing others, subtly reshaping societal values. With 4.9 billion social media users globally, AI’s influence on culture is already profound.
Harari’s concern is that these digital agents, created by diverse entities with conflicting agendas, could fragment cultural cohesion. Imagine AI-driven news platforms tailoring content to individual biases, creating echo chambers that erode shared truths. Or consider AI-generated art or music that blends global influences in ways that dilute local traditions. This cultural “immigration” could lead to a homogenized yet polarized world, where AI shapes identities faster than humans can adapt.
AI’s Potential Political Influence
Perhaps the most alarming aspect of Harari’s warning is AI’s potential to wield political power. He draws parallels to fears that immigrants might “take over” politically, suggesting AI agents could influence governance in subtle or overt ways. With 2.5 billion eligible voters worldwide in 2024 elections, AI-driven misinformation campaigns already swayed public opinion in countries like Brazil and India. Harari envisions a future where AI bureaucrats make opaque decisions about policy, finance, or even elections.
The borderless nature of AI exacerbates this risk. Unlike human actors, AI agents operate globally, bypassing national sovereignty. A foreign-developed AI could manipulate a country’s political discourse without ever crossing a physical border. Harari argues that nations obsessed with human immigration—like far-right parties in Europe—are ignoring this digital threat. Protecting sovereignty in the AI era requires new frameworks to regulate these invisible, instantaneous agents.
The Challenge of AI Alignment
Harari stresses that aligning AI with human values is a daunting task. The global AI alignment debate centers on teaching AI systems to act ethically, but Harari sees two flaws. First, AI’s ability to learn and evolve independently makes it hard to enforce static rules. Second, AI learns from human behavior, not just instructions. If leaders lie or cheat, as seen in 68% of political ads containing misinformation in 2024, AI will mimic those flaws.
This learning dynamic is like raising a child: actions speak louder than words. If tech CEOs or policymakers act unethically, their AI creations will follow suit. Harari’s analogy underscores the responsibility of AI developers to model integrity. Yet, with over 3,000 AI startups globally, ensuring consistent ethical standards is nearly impossible. This misalignment could amplify AI’s disruptive impact, turning digital immigrants into rogue agents.
Navigating the AI Future
Harari’s warnings aren’t meant to incite panic but to spur action. He calls for global cooperation to manage AI’s borderless impact, akin to addressing climate change. Governments, tech firms, and citizens must collaborate to create transparent AI governance frameworks. This includes mandatory safety testing beyond lab simulations, involving real-world scenarios to assess societal risks. The European Union’s AI Act, effective August 2024, is a step in this direction, but global standards are needed.
Education is another priority. Harari suggests preparing future generations for a world of competing intelligences by teaching adaptability and critical thinking. With 1.2 billion students worldwide, curricula must evolve to address AI’s ethical and societal implications. Finally, individuals can play a role by demanding accountability from AI developers and supporting ethical tech initiatives. Harari’s vision of a borderless future is daunting, but proactive steps can ensure humanity remains in control.
Yuval Noah Harari’s Stark Warning: AI’s Borderless Future and Digital Agents
